The CBB
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/

A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=7916

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Tue May 25, 2010 8:03 am ]
Post subject:  A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

What if Doris didn’t die and Mary Lou had to choose between her Mother and her career?

This is set at the end of the summer after Future. In Wins the Trick, Roland Carey, father of Verity and stepfather to Mary Lou died leaving the pair and Doris alone. Len and co discuss what is going to happen to Mary Lou as Len believes it will mean the end of Mary Lou becoming an archaeologist. Mary Lou returns to St Millie’s unsure what she’ll do and Joey invites them to come and stay for the summer. This is set at the end of the summer

“Thanks Auntie Jo,” said Mary Lou giving her brevet aunt a hug. “You’re welcome Mary Lou,” answered Joey Maynard, holding the girl close to her.
“I do think you’re being awfully brave and I’m proud of you.”

Mary Lou hid her annoyance at Joey’s words, knowing Joey meant well, but also knowing full well Joey Maynard couldn’t possibly understand what it was like.

“Thanks Aunt Joey,” she said pulling away. “Well, we better be off, it’s a bit of a journey back and I would like to get Mother comfortable.”
“Okay then. Are you sure you don’t want Jack to drive you to Basle at least?” Offered Joey. Mary Lou shook her head, “No thanks, though it is awfully nice of Uncle Jack to offer.” Mary Lou hurried off and joined Verity and her Mother in the carriage.

“Bad?” Asked Verity with a sympathetic smile.
Mary Lou sighed and shook her head. “It’s not too bad I guess and I know she means well, it’s just, it’s just she doesn’t understand. She can’t possibly know what it’s like. I’m sorry Verity, I know she’s been giving you little digs all along.”
Verity smiled again, slightly ruefully this time, “she wasn’t the only one. I don’t think Len, Con or Margot have much of an idea either.”
“I know,” said Mary Lou with a sigh, “and I did try to explain to Len, but in all honesty I don’t know if she understood or ever will.”

The two girls shared a look which spoke of the closeness of their relationship, which was a mixture friendship and family. Mary Lou turned to look at her Mother who was already dozing on the comfortable, makeshift bed her two daughters had made for her. Mary Lou gave her a soft look and felt a deep wave of thankfulness that Verity understood and wasn’t offended because she didn’t want to leave her Mother alone. :lol:

Author:  2nd Gen Fan [ Tue May 25, 2010 8:47 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make

This looks a really interesting idea - I know many of us love to bash OOAO on occasions, but it's nice to see a sympathetic story written from her viewpoint. A very good point made that Mary-Lou might actually want to be with her mother. I look forward to seeing where this goes.

Author:  JB [ Tue May 25, 2010 8:49 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make

Thanks, Fiona. What a great idea for a drabble. As someone said in the thread on Wins The Trick, we never do see this time from Mary Lou's point of view.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Tue May 25, 2010 9:46 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make

Thankyou - can't wait to see where this goes, it looks fascinating!

Author:  Alison H [ Tue May 25, 2010 10:36 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make

Oh good, I was hoping someone'd write this :D .

Author:  PaulineS [ Tue May 25, 2010 10:56 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make

Thank you for an intriguing start to a new drabble.

Author:  Chair [ Tue May 25, 2010 11:53 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make

Thank you for starting this drabble, Fiona. It is interesting to see this from Mary-Lou's point of view.

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Tue May 25, 2010 11:51 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make Update 26/5

Mary Lou’s thoughts wandered back to the conversation she had with Len.
“I don’t understand Mary Lou,” said Len, “I really don’t. Why can’t Verity look after Auntie Doris? It’s not fair that you have to give up all you’ve worked for, dreamed about, simply because Verity is too moony to take charge.”

Mary Lou gave a sigh of impatience. She just doesn’t understand what it’s like she reminded herself and sighed again, only this one was more of weariness. She had already had this discussion with Aunt Joey and she was very well aware that Aunt Joey had discussed with Verity about her perceived selfishness. Thank goodness Verity was such a good friend as well as sister, because really, Aunt Joey was becoming too much, so much so Mary Lou nearly felt like losing her temper, something she rarely felt like doing. Instead she was sitting on the grassy bank with Len overlooking the Jungfrau. Con and Verity were sitting further on, discussing poetry and music of all things, while Ruey and Margot had decided to walk further on.

“Len,” said Mary Lou at last, “it’s not because Verity is too moony to take care of Mother. She could. Verity adores Mother and has said she would be more than happy to live with her. I could see Mother being very happy with her too.”
“Then what’s the problem?” questioned Len bewildered. “If that happened, then you could still have your career and know Auntie Doris will be okay.”

Mary Lou turned to look at Len; out of all the triplets, Len was the one she identified with; both of them had had huge responsibilities placed on them and it was for that reason Mary Lou had said what she did a year ago. She knew firsthand what it was like to be responsible for a sister, who was the same age, -and what it was like to resent them for it. Mary Lou gazed in Verity’s direction. The two of them had become so much closer since Roland’s death. They had finally talked about so many things to do with their Fathers’ going to the Amazon jungle when they were both only two. Mary Lou turned back to Len, what Verity seemed to understand almost instinctively, Len was struggling to.

“Len,” she began quietly, “Mother and Verity are my own family, and they are all I have left. It would be different if Dad was alive, because Mother would have her own life with him and it wouldn’t be right to hang around. Kids need to leave the nest so to speak and it would give Mother and Dad a chance to have their time alone without us around. Now it means Mother will be alone, and so it’s different.”
Mary Lou took a deep breath, what she was about to say was deeply personal and something which she had told few people and she wondered if Len would even understand.
“Len, my Father left his family when I was two and he was gone eight years before we knew he was never coming back. I saw what it did to Mother and Gran; I saw how much they missed him and how they grieved when he didn’t return. I know he was a hero and he died for his friends, but a part of me is angry he didn’t want to live with us, his family. Why did he leave me when I was two, weren’t we good enough for him, didn’t he want to know me? I understand, that was his job, but I saw what it did to Mother. She missed him every day of her life, and I won’t do that. I will not be like my Father and put my Mother through that kind of grief and loneliness, not when she’s alone, not now.”
“But your Mother would have Verity, wouldn’t she?” Asked Len slowly.
“It’s not the same,” said Mary Lou simply, “I know Mother loves Verity and Verity adores her. She was the first adult who cared about Verity for her own sake and who didn’t leave her either through work or dying. But it’s not the same. It would be like you and Ruey as much as Aunt Joey loves Ruey and see’s her as family, you’re her daughter, her own flesh and blood and she has loved you, knowing you were her own, not someone else’s for a few years before they became their own. And anyway, I want to be with my mother, regardless.”

“I see,” said Len slowly. “I never thought of it like that. All I could think of is how much I would hate to give up my own dreams for Oxford and to be a teacher, especially if it’s because my sister wouldn’t share the responsibility so to speak.”
Mary Lou gave Len a curious look, as Len went red. “You still feel burdened don’t you,” she said.
Len nodded. “I know how much my parents need me and the younger ones. I may have stopped looking after Margot and Con, but that doesn’t mean I get to stop with the rest of them.”
It was Len’s turn to take a deep breath, “Mike went down the cliff last summer and yes we got him back, but then Mamma fainted and Papa was so angry and wouldn’t talk to him for the next few days. Everyone looked to me and I had to take care of Mike as well. It didn’t matter what you and Auntie Hilda had said, I still had to be responsible for family. It wasn’t going to end, just because the two of you said I shouldn’t. I did talk to Papa about it, especially when he said we three should help out more, and he understood and made sure it shared between the three of us, but there is still that expectation of me. At least Oxford means I will be away from all of this and I am free of all that expectation, that’ll I’ll always help, always be responsible. At least there I can be me, find out who I really am; not just be the responsible triplet.”
“I’m sorry Len, I had no idea you really felt like that,” said Mary Lou giving Len a long look. “I’m sorry it’s like that for you. It’s a lot easier to say you shouldn’t be responsible like that but much harder to do. I can see why going to Oxford would make the break from it so much easier.”
“I just feel bad for you Mary Lou,” said Len softly, “you were really looking forward to Oxford and being an archaeologist.”
“I’ll still have Oxford,” said Mary Lou with a faint grin, “and I’ll work as a curator for a museum. It won’t be all bad and there are compensations. Now we should head back, before our respective mothers’ send out a search party.”

The conversation had ended there, but Len did start to show some understanding, Auntie Joey couldn’t seem to at all, she didn’t seem to understand that for Mary Lou, there were some things more important than a career and families, for Mary Lou was one of them.

Author:  keren [ Wed May 26, 2010 4:15 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Wonderful insights

Author:  Lesley [ Wed May 26, 2010 4:45 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Hope Len can understand - but where is Joey's famed insight?


Thanks Fiona

Author:  Alison H [ Wed May 26, 2010 5:42 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Joey's never really been in this position - Madge must've given up a lot to look after her when they were young, but it's not something that's ever been asked of her. Interesting to see Mary-Lou's thoughts about what her father put her mother through. Thanks Fiona - this is fascinating.

Author:  JS [ Wed May 26, 2010 7:44 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Good for Mary-Lou - hope it works out for her.
Thanks Fiona.

Author:  JB [ Wed May 26, 2010 9:04 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Thanks, Fiona. I'm really enjoying this. I love the way you're showing the friendship between Mary Lou and Verity, something that I don't feel EBD portrayed well as they grewolder, and it's so undertandable that Len would project her own feelings onto Mary Lou.

Author:  PaulineS [ Wed May 26, 2010 10:53 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Hope the talk with Mary Lou helped Len.

Author:  Elbee [ Wed May 26, 2010 11:19 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

This is really good seeing it from Mary-Lou's perspective, and I like the way Mary-Lou and Len have opened up to each other.

Thanks, Fiona.

Author:  Abi [ Wed May 26, 2010 12:09 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Thanks Fiona, this is really interesting.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Wed May 26, 2010 1:11 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

As everyone else says, this is a really interesting read, thankyou.

Author:  2nd Gen Fan [ Wed May 26, 2010 4:39 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

I thought it was good for both Mary-Lou and Len that they could explain how they felt to each other. And a lovely glimpse of Mary-Lou and Verity's relationship.

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Wed May 26, 2010 8:18 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5

Mary Lou kept staring out the window. She was deeply thankful her Mother seemed to be sleeping for so much of the journey. She had been through so much this past summer, and so had Verity. Mary Lou looked at her sister by marriage or rather her step sister with a smile. The two had coined that phrase when they were young and it had stuck all these years. Their relationship had seemed so unique to the two girls, especially when compared with everyone else they knew.
‘I’m so glad I’ve got Verity,’ thought Mary Lou with a soft smile. ‘She truly understands.’

Her thoughts drifted back to the startling conversation she had with Verity at the beginning of the summer. She had been so unsure of how to broach the topic after their Father’s funeral, but instead Verity had broached it for her.
“What do you plan on doing in September?” She asked when the three were united once more in Carn Beg.
“I’m not sure,” answered Mary Lou slowly. “I think I’ll still go to Oxford and study archaeology. I’m not sure what I’ll do with the degree when I have it. I doubt I’ll go dancing off overseas now.”
“No, I can see that,” agreed Verity. “Mother and I were talking about it a few days ago, when we could finally start thinking about what was going to happen and she said she knew you wouldn’t want to go now, even though she doesn’t want you to give up your career for her.”
Verity stopped and looked at Mary Lou speculatively. “You do know I would stay here at Carn Beg and take care of her, she said abruptly. We could manage. And I could care less if I teach singing or not. It’s not the be all and end all like archaeology is for you.”
“I know,” said Mary Lou close to tears, touched by Verity’s words, “but I would feel guilty all the time if I did go off. I know you love her and she loves you, but I do feel like she’s my responsibility, like dad was yours.”
“I know,” said Verity simply.
Mary Lou looked up at her tone. Verity wasn’t just being sympathetic; it was as if she did truly know. Mary Lou wondered for the first time if she could actually voice what she had long kept hidden from everyone.
“I couldn’t leave her, not after Dad did,” she said slowly.
Verity looked at her with understanding. “Do you resent him for leaving?” She asked.
Mary Lou nodded wordlessly. “I know I shouldn’t,” she said, “and I know he died a hero, but sometimes I think he would have been more heroic to stay or at least made sure he came back alive instead of dying. He could have you know? It wasn’t fair to Mother or Gran that he left like that and didn’t come back. They waited so long and hoped so long. It was fair to them. It wasn’t fair to me.” And Mary Lou angrily wiped at the tears that threatened to spill. ‘I will not cry for him,’ she thought.
“I know,” said Verity and she slipped a hand into Mary Lou’s. “I was angry with my Father too.” She gave a faint smile. “You should have heard our first conversation we ever had after he returned.”
“What?” asked Mary Lou looking slightly stunned. “You told him what you thought?”
Verity nodded, her eyes not only dancing at the memory but at Mary Lou’s surprise.
“What did you say to him?” queried Mary Lou.....

.........Verity entered the room. “You wished to see me Miss Annersley,” she said in her clear voice, before noticing her Father. After the first rapturous greeting, Verity turned to face her Father gravely, “why did you leave me Father and for so long?” She asked.
Roland Carey started a little. He hadn’t expected the question or the rapturous greeting. He gazed at his daughter, so like her dead Mother and wondered what he could say. Could he tell her the truth?

“Your Mother,” he started hoarsely and stopped. “Your Mother,” he began again, his voice clearer, “died when you were only a toddler. I couldn’t bear to be around anything that reminded me of her, even you. If I could forget, if only I could forget, even you, then it would be like Lucy never existed and I wouldn’t or couldn’t grieve for someone who didn’t exist. I’m sorry Verity,” he said looking at his daughter’s baffled face.
“You don’t ever forget, no matter which deepest, darkest jungle you’re in. It wasn’t until I was close to dying, that I realised exactly what I was doing and how stupid I was being.” “You’re Mother would have been angry with me for doing it. She loved you so much Verity. And I’m sorry, I’m so sorry for leaving you. I should have stayed.”

Verity felt tears pricking at her eyes. She had never expected her Father to apologise, but it somehow made that little aching hurt, Verity buried deep in her heart, started to diminish. Somehow, after forgiving her Father for leaving her she could understand, it was time to forgive the Germans for the pain they had caused during the War on her Grandfather.....

.......”Grandpapa had lost my Mother and then he lost both his sons during the War, one as a POW a few months after the War ended and the other during the Battle of Britain,” explained Verity softly, “it seemed like it was time to forgive. It did take Father and I awhile to rebuild our relationship, but we did slowly. It just seems such a waste to have lost those eight years he was away for.”
Mary Lou squeezed her hand. “Your Mother was so wonderful,” continued Verity, gazing full at Mary Lou, “she understood, and after Father died, we did talk about it. Father had told her about our first conversation and I told her about how I felt, still feel. For me family is so important, be they the ones you were born with or the one you adopt, and we adopted each other a long time ago.”
“We did,” said Mary Lou smiling, through her tears. “But, I don’t want to be like either of our Fathers’ walking away from our family like that.”
“You wouldn’t be,” said Verity softly. “All children leave home and start their own lives. Your Mother knows that and she would hate for you to give up what you love and dream of doing. You’re not your Father, Mary Lou and you certainly don’t need to make up for his mistakes or pay the price, he should have paid.”
Mary Lou nodded, her throat tight, not knowing what to do or say.

Author:  Chair [ Wed May 26, 2010 9:14 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

Thanks Fiona for these amazing insights. I can totally understand every one of them and I found what Verity said especially moving.

Author:  PaulineS [ Wed May 26, 2010 9:17 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

In fact by the time Mary Lou qualified archeologists could work in the UK, and not need to spend long periods overseas. Short visits to Italy and Greece would be possible for ML to see sites if she needed to. I have wondered for a while why EBD thought she would have to give up archeology, and as I become more involved with a local archeology group am wondering more.

I am pleased ML is still planning to go to Oxford as i am sure they will help her realise she can work closer to home than she expected to.

Author:  Abi [ Wed May 26, 2010 9:24 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

Thanks Fiona, this makes fascinating reading.

Author:  Alison H [ Wed May 26, 2010 9:30 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

This is lovely. I hate the way EBD turned Verity into a "broken reed" in the later books: this is much better!

Author:  Lesley [ Wed May 26, 2010 9:59 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

This is far, far better than the way visualised by EBD.


Thanks Fiona.

Author:  Luisa [ Wed May 26, 2010 10:56 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

Loving this - thank you.

Author:  Miss Di [ Thu May 27, 2010 12:21 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

PaulineS wrote:
I have wondered for a while why EBD thought she would have to give up archeology, and as I become more involved with a local archeology group am wondering more.


Because Real archeologists dig up tombs in Egypt and temples in Greece, not paddocks where an old house might be on Time Team :twisted:

Author:  JB [ Thu May 27, 2010 7:49 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

I can just see the younger Verity having that conversation with her father. That was very moving, Fiona.

Author:  MaryR [ Thu May 27, 2010 12:54 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

I can totally understand Mary-Lou's reasoning and that was always the way I saw it in the books. No one else can take the place you hold in your family or in your loved one's eyes. And the guilt would be enormous if you didn't listen to that inner prompting. Staying is the only option.

Thanks, Fiona.

Author:  shazwales [ Thu May 27, 2010 5:29 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

Mary-lou and Verity seem much more realistic in this.
Thanks Fiona.

Author:  PaulineS [ Thu May 27, 2010 6:25 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

Quote:
PaulineS wrote:
I have wondered for a while why EBD thought she would have to give up archeology, and as I become more involved with a local archeology group am wondering more.

Quote:
Miss Di replied
Because Real archeologists dig up tombs in Egypt and temples in Greece, not paddocks where an old house might be on Time Team



I have just spent a day looking at Roman finds from a dig in Warwickshire in the sixties. The friend I was with dug as a volunteer with an archeologist who went on to head a University department and appears on Time team..

The work done on medieval Britain was performed by British archeologists digging in the nineteenth century, and continued with major digs and significant finds in the nineteen thirties and continues with University teams performing specialist scientific work in Britain since the end of second world war.

Time Team provides a popularist approach to archeology but is based on modern techniques and the people in charge are university qualified archeologists.

Author:  brie [ Thu May 27, 2010 7:18 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

Thanks Fiona, just read this from the beginning. I really like your Mary-lou and Verity

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Thu May 27, 2010 11:49 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 26/5 Update x2

And now, three months later, the three of them were travelling back home. Mary Lou stared out of the window. ‘What if I do the course?’ she thought, ‘who knows what could happen in three years? We could close up Carn Beg and rent a house in or near Oxford. It is only an hour’s train ride from Paddington station and at least then Mother would have both of us for the next three years at least. After that, who knows?’

Verity, sat up, rubbing the sleep from her eyes and saw her sister by marriage looking far more peaceful, than she had for awhile. “You’ve made a decision?” she asked softly. Mary Lou nodded, “I have an idea.” She said.

Two years later, Mary Lou stood in Carn Beg, helping Verity get ready for her wedding. Doris Carey came in. She stood wearing her Mother’s wedding dress and step mother’s veil.
“You look beautiful,” said Doris, simply beautiful.
Verity smiled up at her step mother. “I can’t believe you’re lending me your veil.”
“I told her she should,” said Mary Lou insouciantly, “I thought at least one of Mother’s daughter’s should wear it.”
Well, thank you,” said Verity feeling a little teary. “I need to go get a hanky before I start crying,” and she hurried off before her tears started to fall.

“I can’t believe Verity is getting married,” said Mary Lou, turning.
“You don’t mind do you?” asked Doris a little anxiously.
“No,” said Mary Lou simply, “Alan’s a dear. Are you sure you want to live with them, Mother? I certainly don’t mind you living with me.”
Doris caressed her daughter’s cheek, “I know. I’ll miss you, but I think it’s high time you became selfish Mary Lou. I know you would sacrifice all you want to do, because you love me, but I love you far too much to let you do something that in the end would make you miserable; just as I loved your Father too much to make him stay when he longed to go on the Cameron-Murray expedition.”
“What do you mean?” whispered Mary Lou.
“When you love someone you let them go,” said Doris with a deep breath. “I had to do the same with you Father. I know he loved me, but his job, was his first love. He couldn’t deny it or give it up and I loved him too much to allow him to give it up. If I love him I had to accept that, that was a part of him.”
“I knew he wanted to go on the Murray-Cameron expedition from the first moment he mentioned it, so I told him to go. He would have resented me if I made him stay.”
“Mary Lou, if you love someone, you will let them go and so I’m letting you go, insisting you go. Enjoy the rest of your course; go on those archaeological digs you dream so much about. I don’t know why you love digging in the dirt so much, but I know I’ll be safe and happy living with Verity and Alan.”
“Are you sure, Mother? I’m not letting you down by going? I didn’t want to abandon you the way Father did,” whispered Mary Lou, hardly daring to believe what she was hearing.
Doris smiled, “I told your Father to go, not because I didn’t love him but because I loved him too much not to let him. I didn’t want his love to turn to resentment from having to stay. I couldn’t bear that with him, and I can’t bear that for you.”
“But, I wouldn’t,” whispered Mary Lou. “How could in resent you, my own Mother. I love you.”
“Not now, perhaps, replied Doris softly, but firmly, but I know one day you will and however, much you fight it, it will eat away at you and you would look at me and feel about me differently. You wouldn’t want to, but you would.”
Mary Lou looked at her Mother, not knowing what to say. Part of her wanted to deny she would ever resent her Mother, but another part had to acknowledge that a part of her had wondered the same thing.
“I just didn’t want to leave you, like Father did,” whispered Mary Lou, her emotions in disarray. “I know he died a hero, but I was angry he left at all. I saw what it did to you and Gran.”
“Oh Mary Lou,” and Doris pulled her daughter close, “however, much I missed him, I was proud of him and I did love him, but I was also glad, I helped him find his dreams and become the man he was always meant to be.”
Mary Lou stood silent, fighting with herself- her own desires and her deep love for her Mother.
"Okay, I’ll go,” said Mary Lou suddenly, “thank you so much.” And as she left the room, she turned to look at her Mother, think there was something so gallant, so heroic about her; who no matter how hard things were, loved her family too much not to let them go, no matter how hard it was for her. She suddenly turned, “I think you’re the true hero, Mother,” and race back to give her Mother a sudden hug, before turning around again and leaving
Doris watched her go, “I will miss you Mary Lou, more than anyone will ever know,” she whispered and drew herself together before heading downstairs after her daughters.

Author:  Lesley [ Fri May 28, 2010 4:43 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Awwww, that was so right - and the determination from Mrs Carey showed just whose daughter Mary Lou really was.


Thanks Fiona

Author:  Miss Di [ Fri May 28, 2010 5:56 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thanks Fiona, that was a much more satisfying solution than killing Doris off.

PS Pauline, I love Time Team, I just think that EBD didn't think there was any real archeology 'at home'.

Author:  cal562301 [ Fri May 28, 2010 6:23 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thanks Fiona. A very realistic scene, showing Mary-Lou's mother in a new light. But a very plausible one.

Author:  PaulineS [ Fri May 28, 2010 7:55 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thank you a lovely solution.

Miss Di I was introduced to archeology by Time Team and still love it, but as I learn more about general archeology I realise than many think of it as entertainment rather than "real". I agree that EBD knowledge was very patching, and she made generalisations. My comments were made it the hope that if the drabble continued with Mary Lou at university then an option was for her learn that she could fulfil her dreams in Britain rather than have to go overseas.

Author:  JB [ Fri May 28, 2010 7:56 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thanks for giving Doris a chance to speak, Fiona.

Author:  Alison H [ Fri May 28, 2010 8:03 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thanks Fiona.

Author:  Llywela [ Fri May 28, 2010 8:24 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

This is really nice, and so good to see the internal perspective, rather than the Maynard clan and co simply passing judgement from the outside. Thanks :)

Author:  Mona [ Fri May 28, 2010 11:40 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thank you Fiona. Lovely scene with Mary-Lou and her mother.

Author:  Chair [ Fri May 28, 2010 5:21 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thankyou Fiona for that insight. Doris did the right thing even though it was so hard to do.

Author:  Abi [ Fri May 28, 2010 7:00 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

That was perfect, and as Mary-Lou said, Doris was a true hero. So glad she was able to make Mary-Lou go off and live her dreams.

Thanks Fiona.

Author:  jmc [ Sat May 29, 2010 3:27 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thanks Fiona, I've just read this from the beginning and it was great to see it all from Mary-Lou's point of view. Much more realistic.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Sat May 29, 2010 12:11 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thanks for the updates, I'm really enjoying this and it's so insightful.

Author:  sealpuppy [ Sat May 29, 2010 6:10 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

A lovely insight, thank you.
In Prof Trelawney's defence though, I suppose he set off in approx 1938/9 on his expedition and presumably could have got caught up in war-time restrictions on travel to South America? I mean, 8 years is a long time, even for a Victorian expedition, let alone a mid 20th century one!

Actually, no. I'm not sure that defence holds good, now I think of it!

Author:  shesings [ Sat May 29, 2010 6:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Lovely, Fiona! And so much more realistic than EBD................

Author:  La Petite Em [ Sat May 29, 2010 7:24 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

This will make me read the book in such a different light! Thanks Fiona.

Author:  shazwales [ Sun May 30, 2010 5:40 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Thank you Fiona,really enjoyed reading this,much more realistic than EBDs take on it.

Author:  JS [ Mon May 31, 2010 1:02 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Hard Choice to Make -Update 28/5

Good for Doris - and for Verity, and for Mary-Lou come to that! Thanks Fiona.

Quote:
Time Team provides a popularist approach to archeology but is based on modern techniques and the people in charge are university qualified archeologists.


My husband's bottom featured quite prominently in one episode. (he was diving)

All times are UTC
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/