The CBB
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/

A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=6671

Author:  JS [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 9:52 am ]
Post subject:  A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

andydaly wrote:
Quote:
JS wrote:We only 'see' Mrs Cochrane from the point of view of those who don't like/approve of her. Maybe if we saw it from someone sympathetic towards her, we'd get a different story.

Drabble, anyone?


I took up this challenge and wrote my first drabble over the weekend :oops: . Then I saw that Lesley had tackled the same subject. So, feeling rather daring, I thought I'd post mine anyway (although I think Lesley's version is more convincing). Still, here goes with the first bit....

Taverton
Cornwall/Devon border

15 April 19—

My darling Grizel

How often have I wanted to write or say these words to you. But somehow I can do it only now, when I know this is the last communication you will ever receive from me. I am dying, I know that, so have started to write this in the hope that it might go some way to explain my behaviour to you when you were a child and, I regret to say, when you were an adult also.

I hope you will do me the courtesy of reading this letter, although I wouldn’t blame you if you threw it on the fire, unopened. That’s probably what I would do, in your place. But then, I’ve made so many mistakes in my life and I hope, hope and pray that you might at least read this, even if you can’t find it in yourself to forgive me.

It was a great shock to me to find that your father had a daughter. I’m not sure if you knew, but he didn’t tell me that he had even been married. When I met him I thought it was the first time for both of us. Certainly he didn’t appear to be a married man or even, as I now know he was, a widower. When I met him he was very much the bachelor, living at, dining at his club in town and generally seeming free from any domestic concerns. I had no idea, none at all, that he had been briefly – and so excruciatingly happily – married to your mother and that no-one, no-one at all, could hope to take her place.

He was my first suitor, you know, and I couldn’t believe that he had chosen me. We met through my brother – they were business acquaintances – and right from that first moment, I felt that if only he would notice me, then I’d be the happiest girl in the world. And he seemed to like me too – it was a miracle, or felt like it.

You see, Grizel, he was so handsome and so respectable. My family, well, I know I’ve never let you (or anyone else) know, but respectability was not a claim anyone could make for us. My father, I can now admit, was little more than a fraudster and, although my mother tried to bring us up properly, there was never enough money and we were always moving from place to place. I used to look with such envy at the other girls I would meet. They had piano lessons, ponies, nice clothes to wear and things to eat – all the things you had as a child, Grizel. I, on the other hand, managed to scrape a little education and knew I would have to work for a living.

It was just before I was to take my first job – as a governess, with virtually no salary but with accommodation included – that I met your father. My brother, who, I’m sorry to say, took after my father in his business dealings, was trying to persuade your father to join him in a venture. I think, although it pains me to say it, that my brother thought my ‘charms’ might help persuade your father to invest. He was too smart for that, however. But, although he abandoned the investment, he pursued me.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 10:11 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

This is certainly a side to her that we don't get to see in the books!

Thankyou, this is really good, I feel so sorry for her!

Author:  Alison H [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 10:37 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

That would make a lot of sense.

Author:  abbeybufo [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 10:54 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Fascinating start, JS :D

Looking forward to more ...

Author:  jmc [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 11:13 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Thanks JS. I don't think it hurts at all to have more than one drabble on similar topics. Great start. Looking forward to more.

Author:  Emma A [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 12:12 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Very interesting, JS. And very plausible, too. Looking forward to more.

Author:  MaryR [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 5:15 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Surprising what the thought of imminent demise will do to people! :shock: But I always thought she was more sinned against than sinning, at the beginning. It is Grizel's father who ought to be writing this letter to his only daughter.

Thanks, JS

Author:  Abi [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 9:08 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Interesting to see this from Mrs C's point of view and you can see how horribly difficult it must have been for her. Even so, it doesn't excuse the way she treated Grizel. Still, maybe this letter would help Grizel see things from a different side.

Author:  Lesley [ Mon Oct 05, 2009 9:12 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Can feel sorry for her - she was treated very badly by her husband - but didn't give her excuse to abuse Grizel.

Thanks JS - and congratulations for your first drabble - you've passed the point of no return! :devil:

Author:  JS [ Tue Oct 06, 2009 7:53 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel

Thanks for the comments :) .

Part two:
When we married – and oh, Grizel, it was a whirlwind courtship, just six weeks – he insisted I had nothing to do with my family again. I didn’t mind – my parents were dead and my brother only wanted to make use of me in ways which, even now, I can hardly bear to think about. I think your father saw in me a young, malleable girl, who would ‘do’. I regret to say that I don’t think he loved me, certainly not as he loved your mother.

Your father also explained to me that, as his wife, I would have to behave differently. I had always been an impulsive sort of girl – one of our neighbours used to say I was as ‘friendly as a box-full of puppies’ – but I was told I had to behave more like a fine lady – like the mothers of the girls I used to envy as a child. It was difficult at first, but I knew I had to do it. My background, you see, meant I had to be even more respectable, more above reproach than anyone who had been brought up in your father’s class. Soon I had perfected the air of icy politeness and, although it was lonely, I soon learned it was easier not to let anyone see behind the facade.

But you may be wondering what this had to do with you. Grizel, I didn’t know about you. It was a huge shock to find you there on the doorstep of my new home – a place in which I’d hoped to find happiness, but which looked so large and imposing. My face –I don’t know how much I must have hurt you, oh so unwittingly – but my face must have shown how I felt. I was hurt, confused and felt betrayed. After growing up with people I couldn’t trust, I began to feel that there was nobody in the world who would be truthful to me. And your father – well, I’m afraid he just said that I had to put up with it and, indeed, that one of the reasons he had married me was to have you under his roof again. Grizel, you can imagine how that made me feel.

Nevertheless, I was determined to be happy in my new life, and I quickly tried to make friends with you. You were such a pretty little girl and, at first, I felt so proud to be seen with you. But, no matter how much I tried, you weren’t going to love me, were you Grizel? I knew I couldn’t take your mother’s place with you, but I used to wish that you could at least show me a fraction of the affection you showed our cook. I don't mind admitting that I used to envy her, for many reasons.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Tue Oct 06, 2009 8:04 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - updated 6 Oct

(((Mrs C)))

I'd always assumed that she took against Grizel from the start, but your accunt is so plausible. Thankyou.

Author:  Alison H [ Tue Oct 06, 2009 9:07 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - updated 6 Oct

It's certainly plausible that he remarried partly to "get" someone to look after Grizel, especially if his mother's health was deteriorating by then :( .

Author:  jmc [ Tue Oct 06, 2009 10:38 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - updated 6 Oct

I'm now starting to feel very sympathetic towards someone who I never had any sympathy before. Thanks JS

Author:  JS [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 8:01 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - updated 6 Oct

Last part - thanks for the comments.

I know what you’ll say – that I was the adult and you were a motherless child who had been uprooted from the love of her grandmother’s house; that I should have put up with every rebuff and tried to be the good stepmother I wanted to be in my heart. But it was difficult. I don’t expect you to remember, or even to understand, but you could be cruel to me Grizel. You’d tell me I wasn’t your mother, that you hated me, that you wished your father had never met me. And you hit out at me, Grizel – I still have a scar on my temple where you threw that bookend at me; it barely missed my eye. Do you remember that, I wonder?

I had tried to keep our troubles from your father, but this brought things to a head. He laid down the law and insisted that you must have a more disciplined life. So I hardened my heart and we began the regime I’m sure you do remember. Strict obedience, strict adherence to lessons, to piano practice. Just as I’d learned to shut out the rest of the world, so I did to you, Grizel. And it worked – you never knew what I was thinking – but how much do I regret allowing your father to cow both of us in that way. I should have stood up to him – I should have pointed out that you were an unhappy child. But I was little more than a child myself and didn’t have the courage.

There’s something else you probably don’t know; I don’t think anyone does, apart from the specialist who treated me. After telling me that one of the reasons he had married me was to provide a home for you, your father made it clear that the other reason was that he wanted a son, or sons. Well, I’m afraid it wasn’t to be. Oh, I became pregnant shortly after we were married – what joy that brought – but the baby died. Time and time again I tried – on one occasion the pregnancy lasted 18 weeks – but all ended up the same. Gradually, your father became a stranger to me. He started leading his ‘bachelor’ lifestyle again, and you and I were left in Taverton. You hated me – I know that, and can’t blame you – and I, yes, I resented you, for being a living reminder of my husband’s ‘real’ wife, the he loved; the one who had given him a child.

As you know, I didn’t have any close friends in Taverton, and we always tried to keep up the appearance of a perfect family. But I think that one person saw that all was not as it should be. I think she felt sorry for you, Grizel, and I can’t blame her, but I think she also saw behind my facade to the unhappiness within. That was, of course, Madge Bettany. When she came round that day and asked if you could become the first pupil at her new school, it was like an answer to a prayer. Perhaps – and forgive me for this, Grizel, but perhaps with you gone, your father might be prepared to be a husband to me again. Perhaps I might even have a baby, and perhaps, perhaps he might love me.

That wasn’t to be, as it soon became obvious. I was pleased that you were going, though, and not just for selfish reasons. I was even pleased that you wouldn’t be home for most holidays. I could see that our life here was making you hard – goodness knows, I could recognise in you what had grown in myself – a hard, cold core, reluctant to let anyone in, lest they hurt us again. I did hope that being with Madge Bettany – a natural, confident, loving woman – would show you that life didn’t have to be like mine. I told myself you were better off away from me, from England and from my influence.
You did so well at school and I know you felt thwarted in your dreams of how you would lead your life. And, I didn’t help, did I? Again, I can only say that I’m so, so sorry. I had no influence with your father, but perhaps I could have tried harder to let you pursue the career you wanted. And, I know you have never forgiven me, but you do realise, don’t you, that there was nothing I could do to release funds to you to allow you to go to New Zealand. Your father tied things up so tightly that he controlled us in death as much as he did in life.

I do hope, my dear Grizel, that your life in New Zealand with your good friend Deira has brought you some happiness. And I hope too, that you haven’t allowed what was a very unhappy childhood to mar your life irretrievably.

May I just add one more thing? Your father loved you very much, Grizel, in his way. Unfortunately, his ‘way’ meant that he didn’t show it and that he always wanted to protect you by making sure you followed his plans for you, rather than your own. And he wasn’t all wrong, my dear Grizel. You were a wonderfully gifted musician and it was right that you should have taken your music further – you could have been one of the world’s greats, you know, but I understand that your heart wasn’t really in it. I remember stopping and listening in wonder as you practised – no-one would have thought it was child at the piano. And you were always so pretty.

I wish I could have felt able to say these things to you before, Grizel, but it is only now, when the end is drawing near, that I have the courage. I’m sorry, but I am still a coward and can’t bear to be rejected again, as you have rejected all the overtures – timid, I know – which I’ve made over the years. I can’t blame you for that, Grizel. But please, please, try to understand.

I love you, my darling girl, and admire the beautiful, talented woman you’ve become. I only wish I could have shown it,

All my love, ‘Steppie’.

The End

Author:  shazwales [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 8:16 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

That was a very touching letter,thankyou JS

Author:  Nightwing [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 8:23 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

Thank you, JS! It certainly shows a different side of Mrs Cochrane - although I think even when presenting herself as a victim it shows flashes of selfishness and a lack of self-knowledge.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 8:54 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

Thankyou - that was a touching account. I only hoped that it helped Grizel as well.

Author:  Alison H [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 9:33 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

That's really sad :cry: . I've often wondered if Mrs C's attitude towards Grizel might have been influenced by the fact that she had no children of her own.

Author:  jmc [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 9:44 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

Thanks JS. It has been very interesting to see it from a different viewpoint.

Author:  Emma A [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 4:37 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

That was really interesting, JS, showing us a more sympathetic side to Grizel's stepmother. Thank-you.

Author:  Smile :) [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 5:55 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

Thanks JS, nice to see a more caring side of Mrs C.

Author:  PaulineS [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 8:17 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

Thank you I hope ot helped Grizel and her stepmother

Author:  Abi [ Wed Oct 07, 2009 9:16 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

Interesting to see a sympathetic view of Mrs C. I didn't like the way she tried to justify her behaviour, though. It sounded as though she was trying to shift some of the responsibility onto Grizel who, despite what Mrs C says in the letter, was only quite a young child. Maybe Mrs C wasn't entirely to blame, but she shouldn't try to make Grizel feel that she (Grizel) was. I wonder whether even at this point she fully realised the impact Grizel's home life had on her?

This was interesting and very well written - thanks, JS!

Author:  MaryR [ Thu Oct 08, 2009 4:51 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

I'm not sure, though, that this letter would have helped Grizel, poignant and rather grovelling as it is. I fear it would only have added to her bitterness. How she musty have longed for some of those words of love earlier.

Thanks, JS. A difficult person to write about but you made her very human.

Author:  Elbee [ Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:51 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A letter for Grizel - concluded 7 Oct

A very interesting perspective on their relationship.
Thanks, JS.

All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/