The CBB
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/

The Hardest Apology of All
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=5497

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Sun Jan 04, 2009 8:24 pm ]
Post subject:  The Hardest Apology of All

WARNING: This does concern an issue which some might find upsetting, and it isn't recommended for under 18's. Contains reference to violence.

Sorry it's so bleak, but I read 'Reunion' for the first time recently, and this seemed like an 'accident' too far, particularly given what Joey herself says. Any feedback is appreciated :)

Italicised text is taken from the book.

“All I can tell you is that I was in the den before Mittagessen when I heard a series of screeches, interspersed by loud thuds, and I rushed out just in time to see her ladyship turn a somersault on the bottom step and cannon with a terrific crash into the dower chest. The girls were over at school and Anna was outside hanging up some washing so she didn’t hear a thing. I carried Joey up to bed and there she stays for the moment.”

“She isn’t badly hurt, is she?”

“Well, she’s got the headache to end all headaches and the most magnificent black eye I ever saw.”

It was a full week before Grizel saw Joey again, for that young woman refused to appear in public looking like a prize-fighter.

“People would start giving you a reputation as a wife beater,” she calmly informed Jack.


He mused on this in his study, once the youngest of his terrific brood were in bed, and Joey had settled down to read quietly until he came up. She had complained of the lingering traces of her headache at breakfast this morning, and her smashed ribs still caused her pain if she tried to do anything too heavy, but she was, for the large part, better.

Of course, everyone knew about his legendary temper. More than once his brother-in-law had unhelpfully tried to interfere, and Madge, too, had commented on it. Joey knew better, though. She would never bring up the subject again. She had tried, at the start of their marriage, but she was a quick learner, and her lesson had been well and truly brought home.

He’d come close to being discovered over that affair with Mike some years ago. What Jem had said to him then struck home, but if it kept him from losing his temper badly with the children after that, Joey was another matter. Of course, it was easier with her to keep it a secret. She had so many accidents and adventures that it was nothing out of the ordinary for her to be out of action, and she doted on him so. She would never give him away, hence her latest banishment to bed.

Lying had come easily to him for some time now. He wasn’t sure, but at times it seemed he could read in Len’s eye the realisation of his untruths, and even dreamy Con occasionally glanced at him, startled. But outsiders saw only the respected doctor, the famous healer, the honourable man who had saved so many. He couldn’t lose his reputation now.

He hadn’t been in the den. Taking the chance of Anna being outside, he had gone to confront Joey about an unexplained cheque which had been spent some three days previously. She, of course, had been unable to give a satisfactory explanation, although she mumbled something about needing a new typewriter ribbon. He fancied the more likely explanation was that the new vase in the hallway she promised had been a gift from Daisy Rosoman she’d simply forgotten to put out was actually the cause of the spending. He’d seen in Margot Joey’s fancy for new trinkets which left her unable to resist buying them.

At this, he’d seen red. The vase wasn’t even a nice one, and he should have been consulted before she went out and spent his hard earned money. They’d been near the top of the stairs when he caught up with her. She must have been able to tell what was coming, because she half turned, her hand reaching out wildly for the banister, when he watched himself push his weight forwards.

His hands connected with the base of her spine, and for a second he had contact with her. Then she’d jerked forwards, her body plummeting to the bottom, her shrieks echoing through the narrow staircase. He stood and watched for a few minutes, even when she was lying, still, at the bottom.

He wondered if he would care should she be dead. She wasn’t irreplaceable; Anna could oversee the house, Rösli the coadjutor could look after the children. She’d always surrounded herself with staff, in the mistaken belief that they could somehow save her from being hurt, but all they’d done was make her more dispensable than ever. But, once he’d calmed down slightly, he approached her and checked her pulse. She was alive.

After that his training had kicked in and he’d gotten her safely to bed. But every time he did it, every time she pushed him into hurting her again, he hated her more, he wanted more than ever to lash out at her. He’d never been able to control his temper, he never would, but Joey had known that when she married him. She knew what she was letting herself in for. It was her fault if she made him angry.
Unable to finish his paperwork, haunted by the face of the wife he adored, he sighed and made his way up to bed. She was waiting for him, and put down her book as he approached. Her eye had faded now, though there were lingering traces of a bruise on her ribs. He was startled to see a hint of fear about her. That wasn’t the Joey he knew. Joey understood him, she forgave him. She didn’t stare at him coldly before she turned the light off. She didn’t make him apologise for what he had done.

For a second, it hung on his lips. Then he realised that it was pointless doing so. They both knew that he would lose his temper again. Promises otherwise were mere memories, of days when they were young and carefree. Now they both knew he would never stop.
All they could do was wait for the next time Joey had an accident.

Author:  Lesley [ Sun Jan 04, 2009 8:44 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

That was worryingly realistic. And a scenario that is always hidden.


Thank you for that.

Author:  PaulineS [ Sun Jan 04, 2009 9:07 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Thank you for an intersting start. It is so possble.

Author:  Alison H [ Sun Jan 04, 2009 11:42 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

It seems so frighteningly possible when put like that - thank you for an interesting take on things.

Author:  Emma A [ Mon Jan 05, 2009 10:51 am ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

That was really interesting and chilling in its plausibility. It seems so strange that Jack can admit to himself that he adores his wife and yet treats her so badly. One can just see it all ending tragically.

Thanks, ChubbyMonkey.

Author:  leahbelle [ Mon Jan 05, 2009 2:12 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Frightening, and yet it definitely fits in with what we know of Jack's character. Thanks.

Author:  linda [ Mon Jan 05, 2009 8:56 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Very chilling, but frighteningly possible.

Thanks, ChubbyMonkey

Author:  jilianb [ Tue Jan 06, 2009 7:39 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Thanks chubbymonkey. A very interesting start.

Author:  KJX [ Tue Jan 06, 2009 10:33 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Brilliant - and oh so possible!

Author:  JB [ Thu Jan 08, 2009 7:31 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Excellent, chilling story. It could so easily have been like that.

Author:  Jennie [ Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:12 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

The chilling certainty that he is right in his actions, that Jo deserves what he does to her, and tha he is too deeply entrenched in his abusive behaviour gets to me.

Author:  Clare [ Sun Jan 11, 2009 7:01 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

*Shudders* That was so chilling, and so plausible with the hints we are given in EBD's texts about his temper.

Author:  Lyanne [ Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:25 am ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

That was so scarily believable.

Author:  JellySheep [ Wed Jan 14, 2009 12:15 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

This is really good, and scarily plausible, though I'd never thought of it. I found it especially worrying how Jack can think he adores Jo and still hurt her. Ironic how she jokes about him getting a reputation as a wife-beater - but then it can be liberating saying these things under cover of humour. Don't worry about bleakness - unfortunately it exists.

Author:  Abi [ Fri Jan 16, 2009 11:46 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Only too possible, though you would never think of it. People who seem so good and charming even to people who know them well can be so different underneath. The really scary part is the complete and utter self-delusion - it's *her* fault, not his.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Sat Jan 17, 2009 8:10 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

I'm thinking of writing a follow up to this (in between the mountain of coursework on one side and exam practice on the other X_X) but I really am stuck on it. I'd like to see a character finding out - perhaps Jem, who would seem best qualified to deal with the issue - but I really can't fathom how any of them would react. My instinct is to say there would be some disapproval, but whoever it was (Miss Annersley/Bill, Madge, perhaps Frieda or Simone?) would automatically distance themselves from it out of "good breeding".

If anyone else has any thoughts on the issue, I'd be so grateful to hear them (excusing poor English). I am truly stumped by it.

Thankyou for all of your comments so far, and thankyou for taking the time to read it. It means a lot!

Author:  shazwales [ Sat Jan 17, 2009 9:50 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Thank you for writing this,as other people have said it's a subject that used to get no coverage as 'it didn't happen' in well bred families.
Nice to see it written so sensitively.

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:04 am ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Thanks, that was eerily realistic

Author:  Lesley [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 1:11 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

You would also have the fact that Joey herself would have been brainwashed into thinking it was her fault. And not wanting anyone else to know as she would be too ashamed.

I would hope that, should Hilda, Nell or Madge find out then they would try to do something about it - but it would be exceptionally difficult. Perhaps Jem is the right person - he, more than most, would have had access to the seemier side of life being a doctor - or perhaps even Matey? She might be someone Joey would go to.

Author:  Alison H [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 3:52 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

I'd like to think that any of Joey's friends would help her but, as you say, at that time many people would have considered it inappropriate to "interfere" in the relationship between husband and wife.

How about Daisy? She was living on the Platz by then, and Joey might have felt more comfortable consulting her for medical advice than one of the doctors at the San who were Jack's colleagues. Although it's never said in so many words, it's strongly hinted in the books that Daisy's father was a violent husband, so Daisy might have had stronger views on the subject than other people at that time.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 7:10 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Just a small update because, yes, I should be revising *grumbles*. But this was one plot bunny which wouldn't go away, and I always give in to them. My first thought of a person to find out was Margot Venebles because of the hints about her own husband, but I thought she was probably too early. As you can probably tell from this update, I know little of the chronology after the first few books - there are just too many poeple to keep up with who and when!

Thankyou for all of the suggestions - you've all been so supportive, and I can't say thankyou enough.

The Saal was as tastefully decorated as ever, mute and understated, but warm and comforting, homely. It was welcoming to anybody who wanted to tramp through it, and they could be sure of a friendly reception from Jack and Joey. They always insisted that this should be a home away from home for all of their many acquaintances.

The latest person to come over was Daisy, on a break from her course. She had decided to spend the holidays with the people who had been a family to her when her own family couldn’t be, and had delighted in spending time with many of the small fry who frequented the nursery. She’d missed the warmness and the sense of belonging.

“Joey,” she said, somewhat awkwardly, a small flush reddening her cheeks. Joey looked up from pouring tea from both of them. “About last night – “

“Forget it,” smiled her host smoothly. Jack had come home from the Sanatorium in a bad temper which he had been unable to conceal from his guest. Shortly afterwards, she’d excused herself to go to bed, letting husband and wife have some precious time alone.

“It was just that – well, I recognised the look he gave you. Once I’d gone to bed, I couldn’t help hearing things. I wanted to make sure that everything was ok.”

“Fine,” replied Joey readily, absorbed in making the tea. “I tried to stand up too quickly and knocked over the coffee table, that’s probably what you heard.”

She called to Anna for some more biscuits, anything to change the topic, but she should have known that with Daisy that wouldn’t work. Once Anna had gone, the younger of the two women continued to frown, until she offered quietly,

“You can tell me anything. We all know that we can come and confide in you whenever you need, well, you need someone too. I’m more than happy to listen.”

“Daisy,” said Joey, just a touch too sharply. “I understand that you must have had a difficult childhood, but that doesn’t mean you can assume everyone else is like your father. Jack and I are fine.”

“That’s what mum used to say,” she said pointedly. After that tea continued in a frosty silence. It was only when Joey stood up to move the tea tray that her suspicions were confirmed, for her adopted aunt-cum-sister fell back on to the sofa with a gentle cry as she tried to rise. She batted Daisy’s concerned exclamations away, though.

“I told you, I knocked the coffee table over last night. I’m just slightly bruised. I told Jack it wasn’t as bad as it was so he wouldn’t confine me to yet another dull few days in bed with nothing to do and no visitors. You mustn’t tell him.”

Daisy sighed. Clearly this was pointless. She tried one last attempt at coaxing Joey to talk to her.

“We could talk to Uncle Jem, he’d know what to do. He’s a doctor, he must have met this before. He’ll be able to help.”

“No,” said Joey finally. “Then Madge would be upset, and I won’t have it, not in her condition. You’re to say nothing. Promise me.”

Daisy sighed reluctantly but gave her promise.

Author:  Lesley [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 8:32 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Daisy - being an adult means that sometimes you must choose to break a promise.


Thanks.

Author:  Alison H [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:51 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Glad that you've decided to write more of this - it's sad but could so easily have happened.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 10:06 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Thankyou for your suggestion! I don't really feel like I'm doing much work towards writing it, everybody else is helping.

Author:  Emma A [ Mon Jan 19, 2009 2:34 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

I really hope Daisy goes back on her promise - Joey could be seriously hurt - and Jack can't be allowed to continue this treatment of his wife. Looking forward to more when you can, ChubbyMonkey.

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:33 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Can understand the awkwardness Of Daisy's position. She will be wondering if she'll only make things worse by telling Jem or Madge especially against Joey's wishes. Jack and Joey could deny everything and Jack could then take it out on Joey even more. Joey will need to be ready to face the truth before she could ever deal with whats happening

Thanks chubbymonkey, and good luck with all your studies at the moment

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Tue Jan 20, 2009 7:07 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Hurrah! Exam period is over! To celebrate, here is the update. For now, I'm going to say it's the final one, because I want to avoid getting repetitive, but if you do want some more for some odd reason, just ask, I have a couple of ideas bouncing around.

It was a full three days later. She stood outside, watching the house intently as if it could help her. Joey had stayed in bed that morning – Jack said she’d been in too much pain from the bruises over the coffee table affair, and needed a few days rest. She didn’t believe him. There was only one person who, in her mind, could solve this, because he was the only one with any control over willful Joey.

Jem strode into the bedroom, grinning cheerily, despite his inward quaking. Joey was reclining against the bed pillows, a pathetic sight. Her black hair fanned around her, a direct contrast with the clinical whiteness of the sheets. She smiled as he approached, but groaned when she tried to sit up and greet him properly.
“Steady on, old girl,” he laughed lightly. “No need to get excited. Daisy asked me to come over, she said that you’d injured yourself. What have you been up to this time?”
He played along with her chatter, accepting her explanation without comment, not challenging her, even when she said that she didn’t want him to examine her. Anna brought them up a tray of tea and her special biscuits, and they sat down to catch up on the hanes. Joey hadn’t been over to see Madge for some time – something about Jack being busy with work at the moment and the children needing her – nor had Madge been invited, so there was a lot to say.
This filled up nearly half an hour, but once satisfied that Joey knew everything she needed to, Jem settled down and watched her intently. She blushed after a few seconds, and suddenly dropped her gaze. He sighed.
“As I said, Daisy came to see me. She told me other things too, Joey.”
Her face whitened, and she lay back against her pillows again, but she didn’t say anything else. Jem looked into the clear cut face, and his expression softened into one of genuine love. To him, as to many other people, she would never be much older than the time she broke bounds to try and go to the ice festival, or she jumped into the lake. All the times he’d come into contact with Madge, she’d been there. He’d taken her under his wing too, filling in the role of father now that Dick had gone. That had always been an unspoken agreement between him and Madge.
“Joey, old girl,” he sighed. “You can talk to me. I’m not likely to start judging you and Jack now, am I?”
Suddenly she let out a dry sob and flung herself into his arms, until he was cradling her as if she was no older than Ailie. For a while she simply cried, small, choking sobs that tore at his heart. It was all the proof that he needed to tell him Daisy had been correct in her assumptions.
“It’s my fault,” she said shakily, once the tears had nearly stopped. “I just want to make it perfect for him but I can’t and, oh, Jem, you couldn’t understand.”
“I could,” he promised. He was still holding her, his breath regular, even, comforting. “I once had to treat a woman – a dancer – whose husband thought she should give up her career and devote herself to him. One night he just got too angry. She’ll never walk again. I understand more than you think, Joey baba.”
The sound of the childhood nickname set Joey off again, and it was some time before Jem could calm her down. In the end, what sobered her most was Jack, calling her name. The pair listened to his footsteps, running up the stairs, then throwing open doors – to the nursery, to the triplet’s bedroom, then the one to their bedroom.
He didn’t appear at all fazed by his superiors presence, but instead glanced at him.
“Any problems?” he asked quickly. “I just left the San, I thought everything was sorted for the night.”
“It isn’t that,” said Jem grimly. “Can we talk in the study, please?”
Jack nodded, slightly puzzled, and lead his brother-in-law from the room. Joey was left alone, trying to scrub at her face some more, trying to pretend everything was going to be fine.

She was due to go to the Chalet School the next day, but still confined to her bed – now for even more obvious reasons – she couldn’t make it, and sent Jack instead. Miss Annersley and Miss Wilson were waiting, but looked up as he came in.
“Jo can’t make it,” he smiled. “She was hanging out the washing yesterday and decided it would be a good idea to fall backwards over the basket. She’s banged her head and given herself mild concussion as well as a scorcher of a black eye. She says she’ll be over as soon as she can.”
They accepted his story happily. After all, what possible reason could Jack Maynard have to lie?

Author:  Lesley [ Tue Jan 20, 2009 7:35 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Oh no! But that makes it even worse - Jem hasn't been able to help has he! :cry:

Author:  Emma A [ Tue Jan 20, 2009 8:00 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Poor Joey. At least she's been able to admit it to someone else, and that could be the start of learning that what Jack is doing is unacceptable. Still, if Jem tries to force Jack into anything, Jack will only blame Joey. The only solution would be if Joey could leave him - but with nine children (it is, at this point, isn't it?) it would be almost impossible for her. :cry:

Author:  PaulineS [ Tue Jan 20, 2009 9:43 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Jem has made it worse in the short term at least. :devil: :devil:

I hope he can help in the future as Jo will be seriously hurt sooner rather than later if not. :banghead: :banghead:

Well done Daisy at letting Jem know about the situation. :halo: :halo:

Author:  Ruth B [ Wed Jan 21, 2009 12:18 am ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Jem! Why on earth did you leave her there???

Author:  Alison H [ Wed Jan 21, 2009 12:46 am ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

At least Joey didn't tell Jem that Daisy'd got it wrong, but sadly Jem hasn't been able to be of any practical help.

Author:  Cath V-P [ Wed Jan 21, 2009 12:02 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

This is terribly sad and so believable too.

Author:  Abi [ Wed Jan 21, 2009 9:58 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

How can Jem not have helped? He ought to have been able to - he had influence over Jack. Maybe things would get better in the long run. Maybe they wouldn't.

Author:  leahbelle [ Thu Jan 22, 2009 2:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

I wish that Jem had been able to help. Jack will end up injuring Joey very seriously, or even worse, if this continues.

Author:  Fiona Mc [ Sat Jan 24, 2009 8:01 am ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

That is so sad and scarily so believable. I wish Jem had been able to get Joey out of that situation. I guess living so far away from Jem and Madge means Jack isn't really scard of him

Author:  JB [ Sat Jan 24, 2009 6:54 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

Oh no. How awful. I really thought Jem could make a difference.

Author:  ChubbyMonkey [ Sat Jan 24, 2009 8:41 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: The Hardest Apology of All

If it helps, I sort of imagined that being one of the reasons Jack is made Head of the Swiss San - so that Joey can stay with the school and still have her support network, even if Jem and Madge are too busy to be of any use.

I don't know how that would actually fit into the chronology - as I've said before, chronology isn't really my thing xD

All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/