The CBB
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/

A Quintette in Queensland
http://www.the-cbb.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=6725

Author:  Lottie [ Mon Oct 12, 2009 11:47 am ]
Post subject:  A Quintette in Queensland

This is the fourth (and last) of the geography readers commissioned by Chambers and published in 1951. That was the year in which Rosalie and Carola appeared. From the NCC’s website, the following is hardly even a summary.
Quote:
A Quintette in Queensland is almost completely devoid of plot and possibly the weakest of the four. Brent-Dyer's account of a sugar-cane plantation must surely be one of the dullest tales ever told. Moreover, the author made her characters locals, instead of describing everything through the eyes of an English person as with Sharlie and Verena.

There is a copy in the National Library of Australia. There are also two copies for sale; one is in England for only £480 and another in America for $1327.06!

Have you read this book? If so, do you think it paints an accurate picture of life in Queensland at that time? According to the CS books, Jem’s sister, Margot Venables, lived in Queensland and lost her husband and her sons in the terrible climate there. Did EBD actually know anything about the climate and conditions in Queensland?

Author:  JB [ Mon Oct 12, 2009 11:54 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

This is the only one of the geography readers for which there's a transcript available. I haven't actually read it yet, though.

PM me if you're having trouble finding it.

Author:  Alison H [ Mon Oct 12, 2009 12:17 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

I'm afraid that my "knowledge" of conditions in Queensland in the mid 20th century is largely based on The Thorn Birds (a book I do not imagine EBD would have approved of :lol: ) so I can't really comment on how accurate this is or isn't, but I can confirm that it's really not very interestingly-written at all!

Author:  Jennie [ Mon Oct 12, 2009 1:35 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

Do read the book, especially if you have troubel sleeping. It's enough to bore anyone to sleep.

Author:  JB [ Mon Oct 12, 2009 1:44 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

I've skimmed through this over lunch. I wasn't inspired.

Some of the dialogue between the family members sounded very like the Maynards:

Quote:
She looked at them again, and exclaimed: “Adam, you wretch, you've grown again! How on earth do you expect us to keep you in clothes, I'd like to know?”


Quote:
“Look out, you ass! You'll smash the lot if you go hurtling about like that!”
“My precious china!” Their mother rushed to the rescue.


I thought there as an awful lot of dull family story with the odd fact dragged in. I imagined EBD consulting fact sheets about Queensland (she does thank the News and Information Bureau, Australia in the acknowledgements) and quoting the facts verbatim.

According to Wikipedia, Queensland has 5 climate zones, based on temperature and humidity. I didn't get any sense from this book of the terrible climate in which Margot Venables lived. This is a quote from one of the characters explaning why the climate isn't as bad as people think:

Quote:
“Provided you live sensibly, eat sensibly, and work sensibly, there's no reason why the white man can't do the work. You see, Gwyn, Dad's explained to me that long ago the early settlers wanted to try to live as they'd done in the colder climate which they'd left. They wanted meat at least twice a day, and beer with their meals—or wine, if that was what they used—and they went round in thick cloth clothes, and all that sort of thing. Well, it just won't do in a climate like ours. I can't go into all the reasons now, but you can think it out for yourself. It's only a matter of commonsense.”

Author:  Emma A [ Mon Oct 12, 2009 3:25 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

Completely OT, but regarding "meat twice a day", I've been reading Darwin lately on South America, and he records the gauchos living almost wholly on a diet of horsemeat, though he also considers that one could only survive on such a diet by the extreme physical exercise of the gaucho lifestyle. But I guess the climate was rather different (he's talking about Argentina-Uruguay sort of area).

Nevil Shute's 'In The Wet', which is set largely in an early 20th century Queensland, gives a good picture of the wet and tropical climate which existed in parts of the state (at least where his characters were living), and the primitive state of the settlers' habitations, which led to isolation during the rainy season.

Sorry for not commenting on the book itself, which I haven't read! :oops:

Author:  Kadi [ Tue Oct 13, 2009 2:16 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

I've lived in this part of Queensland for nearly 17 years but that was in the 1990s and early 2000s. I know what the climate is like but not what life was like back when this book was set. During the wet it is very hot and humid. You can just be standing around doing nothing and have sweat pouring off you. This is the build up till it rains. The rain pours down and feels very heavy. I don't find the dry season all that hot but then I lived most of my life in the tropics.

One thing that made me laugh was the idea of cane toads doing their job. I don't know when people first realised they weren't eating the cane beetles they were introduced to eat. They were actually eating anything but. One of the problems is that the beetles fly and cane toads don't.

I am glad they don't burn the sugarcane at harvest time anymore. When they did my sinuses would play up. It was even worse for asthmatics.

Author:  hac61 [ Tue Oct 13, 2009 10:36 am ]
Post subject:  Re: A Quintette in Queensland

Kadi wrote:
I am glad they don't burn the sugarcane at harvest time anymore. When they did my sinuses would play up. It was even worse for asthmatics.


We lived near a sugar beet factory in Ipswich. I had to be on antihistamines all year round because of the smell. When they weren't processing the beet they were cleaning the system out, which was just as bad.


hac

All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/