#1: La Rochelle query
Author: Jennie, Location: CambridgeshirePosted: Sun May 06, 2007
2:46 pm — In 'The
Maids of La Rochelle' EBD describes them as going to live with Madame Ozanne in
November 1918. Madame Ozanne has a house in Brittany.
Given that the
Armistice was signed in November 1918, would it have been possible for three
English girls to travel to France at that time, or was this just EBD rewriting
history and hoping we wouldn't notice?
#2: Author: Mrs
Redboots, Location: London, UKPosted: Sun May 06, 2007
3:46 pm — I would
have thought it would be possible. Although people didn't (I imagine) go to
France just for holidays then, my great-grandfather certainly crossed the
Channel in 1916 to visit his severely-wounded son. Little knowing that his
other, favourite son would be killed only a few days later, but that's beside
the point. What is the point is that people could and did cross the Channel even
during the war, so I'm sure that a visit to Brittany, which was, after all, not
fought-over, would have been possible after the Armistice was signed.
I
do wonder what it must have been like for people in those parts of France that
weren't fought over, given how much of it had been....
#3:
Author: Jennie, Location: CambridgeshirePosted: Sun May 06, 2007
4:03 pm — It was
the poverty of living in a war-torn country that was bothering me as much as
anything, with so much of the farmland being devastated.
#4: Author: Mrs
Redboots, Location: London, UKPosted: Sun May 06, 2007
4:21 pm — Indeed,
but, thankfully, I don't think the war-tornness reached as far south as
Brittany. And people were far more self-sufficient back then, of course. And the
French are still incredibly regional. So it might have been possible. Then
again, EBD might just have been indulging in a flight of fancy....
#5:
Author: Jennie, Location: CambridgeshirePosted: Sun May 06, 2007
4:30 pm — I think
she might, as the way that the Temple sisters are described shows them to have
been incredibly sheltered for the whole of their lives, so much so that they can
hardly manage, and not just financially, when their father dies. And Janie
(later Janie Lucy) is treated almost as a baby, and certainly as a very young
child, even though she's fifteen.
#6:
Author: JayB, Location: SE EnglandPosted: Sun May 06, 2007
4:48 pm — IIRC
only about ten per cent of French territory was occupied/fought over, and it was
the other side of the country from Brittany.
Maids was published only six years after the
end of the war - EBD couldn't have got away with anything too
improbable.
#7:
Author: Rosie, Location: Land of Three-Quarters SkyPosted: Mon May 07, 2007
2:00 pm — Brittany
lost a good many soldiers (I do have the figures somewhere, but not sure where), just like everywhere else, but being a
very agricultural area it hit hard. Having three extra mouths to feed may have
been quite tricky, but I am not sure about the travel issues... The Breton ports
were favoured by the US Navy, so sailing in when they were trying to get out
might have been a problem!
*supposed to be researching Breton
20th-century history at the mo*